Signal provider evidence worksheet
Keep source requests and review notes without turning them into an independent score.
Educational explanations, fictional scenarios and personal worksheets. No live calls, paid-account test or provider performance certification.
A claim-by-claim record of your review, not a provider rating. Statuses and notes are entered by you; this page does not inspect a service or independently verify its evidence. Nothing is uploaded or saved to a server.
Received is not the same as reconciled
An alert screenshot can be received without establishing when it first appeared. A spreadsheet can be received without its counts matching the advertised percentage. “Reconciled by you” means you have recorded how a claim connects to its supporting record; it is not an external audit label. Preserve the original source, its date, the calculation and any remaining limitation in the notes.
The evidence-pack guide explains each request. In its hypothetical 100-alert example, 10 cancelled and 20 unfilled alerts leave 70 completed trades, of which 40 win. The 57.14% completed-trade win rate needs that definition. Receiving the ledger is one step; checking its classifications, totals and revision history is another. A service with an unresolved denominator should remain unresolved rather than receiving an invented score.
Review the same product over the same period
A personal account, a model's hypothetical record and a subscriber's funded account are different evidence subjects. A genuine record for one cannot silently stand in for another. Match the model version, channel, tier and continuous period before comparing results. Ask how open exposure and overlapping positions enter the calculation, and whether the displayed gain is gross or net.
Costs and execution can separate a published model result from an achievable account result. The SEC performance-claims bulletin identifies actual-versus-hypothetical results, expenses and the period shown as important distinctions. A publication timestamp, by contrast, answers a field-chronology question. It cannot establish an execution or portfolio return outside its scope.
Keep missing evidence specific
- An unknown source means the question is open, not that the provider is fraudulent.
- A received outside-review report supports only the records, dates and claims its reviewer actually inspected.
- A missing full ledger prevents a completeness conclusion even if one winning call is genuine.
- A matching digest can support the included original fields at an independently checked time; it does not establish uncommitted exits or fills.
- Any commercial or editorial relationship is a separate disclosure question, not something a performance screenshot can settle.
Keep private account details out of public notes. Treat working notes as a personal review record rather than a publishable certification. The evidence exercise tests whether a conclusion follows from its stated evidence, and the track-record checklist provides the broader review sequence.
A filled draft is not a reconciled real provider
The new teaching draft uses the three fictional journal identities, not a named vendor. Original and revision rows are recorded as received; complete financial outcomes, actual executions, costs and independently authenticated chronology remain requested or unknown. These are reader working states, not a certification score. A draft that honestly describes its limitations can be useful even though no account-performance review has been completed.
The original ten claims, JSON import/export and notes remain. A teaching-example command and reset were added, with local processing and no stored drafts. Invalid imports preserve existing notes. Importing literal markup never runs it as code. A pending file read is invalidated after a reset or later edit so old notes cannot quietly overwrite current work. Loading this draft does not perform the missing investigation, authenticate the event source or upgrade received evidence into external review.