Skip to signal lessons
Trading Signals ExplainedMessages / Versions / Evidence

Trading Signal Interpretation Workbench

Parse a signal into explicit identity, clock, conditions, updates and ownership. Record ambiguity before looking at the eventual price path.

Your evidence states are not a provider score, audit opinion or performance finding.

0 documented10 unresolved0 not applicable

RECORD 01

Original wording

What exact instruction was published? A later paraphrase can remove qualifiers or add certainty that the original message never expressed.

Evidence: Original message and source ID

RECORD 02

Instrument mapping

Which venue product does the message refer to? A generic ticker cannot settle contract expiry, currency, multiplier or account eligibility.

Evidence: Executable instrument specification

RECORD 03

Directional meaning

Does buy, sell, close or reduce identify a new or existing position? Direction alone does not explain ownership or an open-close action.

Evidence: Action and position reference

RECORD 04

Entry condition

Which observable event makes the instruction eligible? An opinion about future price is not automatically a complete executable entry rule.

Evidence: Eligibility and trigger condition

RECORD 05

Validity window

When does the instruction expire or become stale? A later price touching the level should not automatically become a retrospectively valid fill.

Evidence: Time boundary and expiry rule

RECORD 06

Invalidation condition

What observation ends the original premise? An intended stop, a thesis change and a broker exit need separate records.

Evidence: Invalidation and exit responsibility

RECORD 07

Quantity instruction

What units and account assumptions determine size? A conviction grade is not a personal probability or a universal position fraction.

Evidence: Quantity basis and unresolved sizing

RECORD 08

Update relationship

Which amendment modifies which original call? Retain the parent identity so revisions do not become additional independent successes.

Evidence: Parent ID and change clock

RECORD 09

Ambiguous case

What remains unspecified when two interpretations are possible? Mark it unresolved before outcomes rather than choose the interpretation that wins.

Evidence: Ambiguity and needed clarification

RECORD 10

Execution distinction

What later order and fill, if any, followed the instruction? Correct parsing does not prove the subscriber could or did execute it.

Evidence: Separate order and execution evidence

Original source, user evidence record and bounded conclusion
Different evidence objects, not a numerical quality ranking.

Primary reference documents

References support source definitions and mechanisms, not a completed review, measured return or endorsement. The questions are this publication's editorial record design.

Ambiguous Trading Instructions: Questions to Ask Before Acting

Keep the interpretation finding narrower than the source claim

The original ten-field record remains a personal evidence worksheet. A documented original message, unclear effective revision and absent actual fill can coexist within one case. Alpha's receipt inversion is an applicability question, Beta's expiry is unfilled in the teaching record and Gamma's withdrawal lacks a closing fill. These are specific findings, not numerical provider ranks or outside certifications.

The CSV inspector offers an adjacent structural check on invented or reader-entered rows, while this workbench retains references and unresolved notes. Its filters alter only the display, and import/export remains a working-record transfer. A complete field list does not grant proprietary model code, paid-account access, execution permission or calibrated probabilities. Useful original source references and negative cases remain, and no financial winner, real reviewer count or measured delivery speed is invented to complete the form.

Filled instruction and receiving references